Should I Publish Traditionally Or Self-Publish?
Understanding the Differences
To start, it's important to understand the fundamental differences between self-publishing and traditional publishing.
Traditional Publishing: In traditional publishing, you work with a publishing house, either big or small, that acquires the rights to your manuscript. The publisher handles the production, distribution, and marketing of the book. Typically, you will need to secure a literary agent who will pitch your manuscript to publishers. Once a publisher agrees to acquire your manuscript, they offer you a contract, often with an advance payment and royalties on sales. The publisher takes on most of the financial risk and is responsible for the editorial, design, and distribution processes.
Self-Publishing: Self-publishing, on the other hand, involves you as the author taking on the responsibilities typically handled by a traditional publisher. You retain full control over your manuscript, cover design, pricing, and distribution. Platforms such as Amazon Kindle Direct Publishing (KDP), Smashwords, and IngramSpark enable authors to self-publish e-books and print books, allowing them to sell directly to readers without the need for a traditional publisher or agent. While self-publishing puts you in charge of all aspects of your book’s release, it also means you assume the financial risk and must handle the marketing and promotion on your own.
2. Pros and Cons of Traditional Publishing
Pros of Traditional Publishing
Professional Support: One of the biggest advantages of traditional publishing is the professional support you receive. Publishers have teams of editors, designers, and marketers who can help improve your manuscript, create a professional-looking cover, and promote your book effectively. This means you can focus on the writing itself while experts handle the other aspects of the book’s production and distribution.
Wider Distribution: Traditional publishers have established relationships with distributors, bookstores, and retailers. This often means greater visibility for your book in physical stores and on major online platforms. Books published traditionally are more likely to be stocked in brick-and-mortar bookstores, libraries, and major e-book stores, increasing your chances of reaching a broader audience.
Credibility and Prestige: Being published by a well-known publishing house can lend credibility to your work. Many readers and industry professionals still view traditional publishing as a mark of success, and it can open doors to additional opportunities such as speaking engagements, book tours, or collaborations with other authors. Traditional publishing also offers you the potential for awards, media attention, and high-profile reviews.
Advance and Royalties: With traditional publishing, you typically receive an advance, which is a lump sum paid upfront by the publisher. This can be a financial cushion to help you focus on writing your next book. In addition to your advance, you earn royalties on the sale of your book, typically a percentage of the book’s price. If your book becomes a bestseller, you can earn significant royalties over time.
Less Financial Risk: Because the publisher bears the production and distribution costs, traditional publishing involves less financial risk for you as the author. The publisher assumes responsibility for printing, marketing, and shipping the books, so you don’t have to worry about upfront costs or paying for professional services like editing or cover design.
Cons of Traditional Publishing
Longer Timeline: Traditional publishing is often a slow process. First, you must find an agent who is willing to represent your manuscript, which can take time. Once your agent submits your manuscript to publishers, the process of securing a publishing deal can also take several months. After signing a contract, the book may not be published for a year or more due to the time needed for editing, design, and marketing. This can be frustrating for authors who are eager to see their work in print.
Limited Control: While traditional publishers provide professional support, they also take control of many aspects of the book’s creation. From the cover design to the marketing strategy, publishers often make decisions with only minimally consulting the author. This lack of control can be challenging for writers who want to maintain creative autonomy over their work.
Highly Competitive: The traditional publishing industry is incredibly competitive, and securing a literary agent or a book deal with a large publisher can be difficult. Publishers receive thousands of submissions each year and typically only accept a small percentage of them. It can take time and multiple submissions to get your manuscript noticed.
Lower Royalties: While traditional publishers offer advances and royalties, the royalty rates are often lower than those offered in self-publishing. A typical royalty for a traditionally published book can range from 5% to 15% of the book’s retail price. In contrast, self-published authors can earn a much higher percentage, often 60% to 70% of the sales price, depending on the platform.
Uncertain Outcome: Even after you sign a publishing deal, there’s no guarantee that your book will be a commercial success. Publishers invest considerable resources into marketing books, but the fate of your book is still largely determined by the market. If your book doesn’t sell well, it could negatively impact your future publishing prospects, and it may even lead to you being dropped by the publisher.
3. Pros and Cons of Self-Publishing
Pros of Self-Publishing
Full Creative Control: One of the biggest benefits of self-publishing is the ability to control every aspect of the book, from the title and cover design to the pricing and marketing strategy. You can choose the exact direction of your project without having to compromise on creative decisions. This is especially important for authors who want to maintain full artistic freedom.
Higher Royalties: Self-published authors typically earn a higher percentage of each sale. For example, when publishing on platforms like Amazon KDP, authors can earn up to 70% of the sale price for e-books.
Faster Time to Market: Self-publishing allows you to publish your book as soon as it’s ready. Once you finish writing and editing your manuscript, you can upload it to a platform like Amazon, and it could be available for sale within a matter of hours or days. This speed is invaluable for authors who are eager to see their work in print or need to release their book quickly for marketing or financial reasons.
No Gatekeepers: In traditional publishing, literary agents and publishers act as gatekeepers. With self-publishing, you are your own gatekeeper. You don’t have to wait for approval from an agent or publisher, and you have the flexibility to publish on your own terms. This is particularly appealing for authors who want to bypass traditional publishing barriers.
Global Reach: Self-publishing platforms like Amazon KDP and IngramSpark allow you to distribute your book globally. Your book can be available for sale in multiple formats (e-book, paperback, audiobook) and in countries around the world without having to negotiate with foreign publishers or agents. This gives you access to a global market of readers.
Cons of Self-Publishing
Upfront Costs: While self-publishing doesn’t involve giving away rights to your manuscript, it also means you are responsible for covering the costs associated with publishing. This includes expenses like editing, cover design, formatting, and marketing. If you want your book to be professionally presented, you will need to invest money into these services, which can be expensive, especially for authors on a tight budget.
Marketing and Promotion: One of the biggest challenges of self-publishing is marketing your book. Without the resources of a traditional publisher, you will need to handle all aspects of marketing yourself. This includes creating a website, running ads, engaging with readers on social media, and potentially hiring a publicist or marketing team. Building an audience takes time, effort, and persistence.
Limited Distribution: Although self-published books can be distributed worldwide, they often have a harder time getting into brick-and-mortar bookstores. Major bookstore chains are less likely to stock self-published books, and it can be difficult to secure shelf space without the backing of a major publisher. Some self-published authors use print-on-demand services, but this still limits physical distribution.
Stigma and Perception: Despite the growth of the self-publishing industry, some readers and industry professionals still view self-published books with skepticism. Although this stigma is slowly fading, traditional publishing still holds a certain prestige. If you plan to pursue traditional publishing after self-publishing, your previous self-published works may impact how agents or publishers perceive your book.
Workload and Responsibility: Self-publishing requires you to wear many hats, from writer to editor to marketer. This means additional time and energy is spent on tasks that are not related to writing itself. If you prefer to focus solely on writing, the added responsibilities of self-publishing may feel overwhelming.
When is it better to self-publish by choice?
Self-publishing is often the better choice if you prioritize control, speed, and niche markets. Here are a few scenarios where it makes sense:
Control Over Your Work: Self-publishing gives you complete ownership of the creative process, including editing, cover design, pricing, and distribution. If you have a strong vision and want to maintain full control, self-publishing is ideal.
Faster Publication: Traditional publishing can take years due to the time required to secure an agent, pitch to publishers, and follow a lengthy production schedule. If your book is timely or you want it published quickly, self-publishing is faster.
Niche or Underserved Genres: If your book targets a very specific audience—such as a local history project or a niche fiction genre—self-publishing can allow you to directly connect with your readers without needing mass-market appeal.
Entrepreneurial Spirit: If you enjoy marketing and want to treat publishing as a business venture, self-publishing offers high rewards for effective effort.
Should I self-publish if I haven’t been offered representation by an agent or publisher?
If you’ve been querying agents and publishers for years without progress, it might be time to self-publish—especially if your rejections are not based on the quality of your manuscript but on marketability or timing. Pay attention to the reasons for rejection. If multiple agents praise your writing but say the book doesn’t fit the market, self-publishing might be a way to reach the readers directly. If your primary goal is to share your story, self-publishing allows you to achieve this without waiting for validation from traditional avenues.
However, consider the following pros and cons:
Pros:
Quick Market Entry: You can avoid the gatekeeping of traditional publishers and release your work to the public.
Higher Royalties: Platforms like Amazon KDP offer authors a much larger share of profits, with royalties ranging from 35% to 70%.
Freedom to Build a Platform: You can begin establishing a readership on your own terms, building an audience that might later attract traditional publishers.
Cons:
No Editorial Guidance: Without a publisher, the responsibility for editing, design, and marketing falls solely on you. A poorly produced book can hurt your reputation.
Limited Access to Bookstores: Most self-published books don’t get physical bookstore placement or traditional media coverage.
Impact on Future Career: If your self-published book underperforms, it might make traditional publishers hesitant to take a chance on you later. Some agents or publishers might just negatively view a previously self-published author, unless you have sold tens of thousands of copies of your project.
IMPORTANT INDUSTRY TIP: If you want a conventional writing career, it may be better for you to accept this project has not led to anything, gather what you have learned about your writing, and start on a new book. Agents, in my experience, would prefer this to your self-publishing first. I am not telling you to do this, far from it, and there are very famous examples of writers who did achieve success this way, but it is a fact of life that if you want a conventional novel-writing career, with book reviews and a copy in Barnes & Noble, you should be aware of this risk.
How should I maximize success as a self-publisher?
You’ve decided to persevere with self-publishing. Consider the following.
Invest in Quality: Hire professional editors, cover designers, and formatters to ensure your book competes with traditionally published titles.
Understand Your Audience: Research your target market thoroughly. Identify their preferences, reading habits, and where they discover books.
Leverage Online Platforms: Use platforms like Amazon KDP, IngramSpark, and Kobo to publish and distribute your book. Take advantage of promotional tools such as Kindle Unlimited or Goodreads giveaways.
Market Aggressively: Build an author platform through social media, email newsletters, and a personal website. Paid ads on Amazon and Facebook can also boost visibility.
Gather Reviews: Early reviews are critical for building credibility. Offer advance review copies (ARCs) to bloggers, influencers, or loyal fans in your niche.
Keep Writing: Success comes from publishing multiple books. Self-publishing is very much about volume and brand, and reader loyalty. Many writers have achieved incredible success with this route.
How To Write A Novel Chapter By Chapter available here: https://www.amazon.com/How-Write-Novel-Chapter-Outlining-ebook/dp/B0DJ8TMVWL?ref_=ast_author_mpb
You can also check out our other services, Mentoring and Manuscript Review, on the links above.