How To Write a Good Villain Or Antagonist

Antagonist from the Greek ἀνταγωνιστής – antagonistēs, "opponent, competitor, villain, enemy, rival."

A story can never be truly compelling without a strong antagonist or villain. While the protagonist’s journey is central to the plot, it is often the antagonist who creates the conflict that drives the story forward. An effective villain challenges the hero, forces them to confront their flaws, and tests their resolve. Without a formidable antagonist, the protagonist’s journey may lack tension, emotional depth, and thematic richness.

But what makes a truly compelling villain? It’s not simply having an evil character who does bad things for the sake of being bad. A well-developed antagonist is complex, multifaceted, and believable. A villain who resonates with readers or viewers can elevate a story from good to great.

Clearly, the villain/antagonist must bring danger/peril to the protagonist. A great antagonist is not just a physical or external threat—they are also a psychological or emotional challenge for the protagonist. The antagonist should target the protagonist’s weaknesses, fears, and vulnerabilities. This could be a literal weakness, such as a fear of failure, or an emotional one, like insecurity or guilt.

In Harry Potter, Voldemort represents an external and internal challenge to Harry. Voldemort's desire for power and control represents a literal threat. Voldemort’s influence forces Harry to become stronger, more courageous, and more self-aware.

But a truly great villain has more qualities than just being evil or dangerous. What else can you to make your antagonist (darkly) shine?

1. Clear and Convincing Motivation

At the heart of every memorable villain is a clear and convincing motivation. While villains often act in opposition to the protagonist, they must have their own set of reasons for doing so. Whether they are seeking power, revenge, or personal gain, the antagonist's motivations should be compelling and grounded in their worldview.

Although psychopathic characters do exist, a villain is rarely evil for the sake of evil. They often have a rationale that, while misguided or extreme, makes sense within the context of their beliefs. A villain’s actions should arise from their internal desires, fears, or traumas. These motivations add depth to the character, making them feel human rather than one-dimensional. Remember, trauma and backstory can be excellent ways to add depth to a villain.

For example, in Les Misérables, Javert is a police inspector who relentlessly pursues the protagonist, Jean Valjean. His motivation is rooted in his rigid sense of justice and his belief in the absolute authority of the law. Though his actions appear villainous, they stem from a moral framework that he believes is right, making him a complex and tragic figure.

2. Relatable or Sympathetic Qualities

The best villains are not purely evil—they often have relatable or sympathetic qualities that make them more complex and interesting. These redeeming traits can humanize the character, making them feel less like a caricature of evil and more like someone who could have been a hero under different circumstances.

Great villains often have a tragic backstory that explains, if not justifies, their actions. A tragic past can humanize the antagonist and give them a sense of depth. By understanding what caused them to become the person they are, the audience is more likely to empathize with them, even if they disagree with their methods.

In The Godfather, Michael Corleone begins the story as a reluctant outsider to the family business, but as he becomes more involved, he is shaped by the violent world around him. His transformation from an idealistic young man into a ruthless mafia boss is driven by his desire to protect his family.

By showing the vulnerability or humanity of the villain, the writer creates a deeper moral dilemma for the audience. Should the audience feel sympathy for a villain, or is their villainy unforgivable? This complexity can lead to a richer emotional experience for the reader.

3. A Personal Connection to the Protagonist Works Well

A compelling antagonist often has a personal connection to the protagonist, which increases the stakes of their conflict. This relationship can range from being a mentor-turned-enemy, a family member with conflicting values, or even a former friend or lover. Alternatively, they are rivals for the same thing, or see each other as two sides of the same struggle. By having a direct link to the protagonist, the antagonist's motivations are amplified. The audience can see the villain’s actions as a personal attack on the hero, making their conflict more intense and meaningful. The more intimate and personal the relationship, the greater the emotional tension between the hero and the villain.

However, it should be noted that some of the greatest villains in literary history do not have a personal connection but rather that the protagonist is blocking their plans, for example, Sherlock Holmes and Moriarty. This works well too, but how this works must be very clear. (Of course, a villain with a personal connection and whose plans are being blocked is two-for-the-price-of-one!)

4. A Clear Set of Beliefs or Ideologies

Many of the most compelling villains have a strong belief system or ideology that drives their actions. This belief system doesn’t necessarily have to be evil, but it should be something the antagonist deeply values. The antagonist may even see themselves as a hero in their own story, fighting for a cause they believe is just or necessary.

Darth Vader is driven by his belief in the superiority of the Empire. His commitment to the Empire’s cause leads him to oppose the Rebel Alliance, and by extension, his own son, Luke Skywalker. That is how deep his beliefs are!

When an antagonist has a clear set of beliefs, it makes their actions more logical and consistent. The audience may disagree with the villain’s philosophy, but they will understand why the villain behaves the way they do. This is the key to a great villain working.

5. Powerful and Intimidating Presence

A strong antagonist should have a certain power or presence that makes them a formidable threat to the protagonist. This could be physical strength, intelligence, or the ability to manipulate others. The villain should naturally create tension throughout the story through direct confrontation or psychological manipulation, and so bring more peril. They push the protagonist to their limits, and just when the protagonist can take no more, they attack again.

6. They Must Have Impact

Finally, a good antagonist should have a profound impact on the world or setting of the story. Whether they are a political leader, a businessman, or an otherworldly entity, the antagonist's actions should shape the world around them in a meaningful way. The protagonist’s actions should be in direct opposition to this impact, creating a larger narrative about change, conflict, and resolution. The conflict then becomes a fight for the future of the world, of right and wrong, raising the stakes beyond just the central relationship. But the victory must always remain personal.

How To Write A Novel Chapter By Chapter available here: https://www.amazon.com/How-Write-Novel-Chapter-Outlining-ebook/dp/B0DJ8TMVWL?ref_=ast_author_mpb

You can also check out our other services, Mentoring and Manuscript Review, on the links above.